You are here:--Sawyer vs Lifestraw – Which Water Filter is Better?

Sawyer vs Lifestraw – Which Water Filter is Better?

In another article, we went over the pros and cons of the Sawyer Squeeze and the Sawyer Mini.  But there's another competitor with a similar style of filter named Lifestraw.  The Lifestraw filter works in the same way as the Sawyer, acting as a straw that filters out contaminants in an on demand fashion.

The on demand part is very important here.  The Lifestraw is not intended for filtering large quantities of water into a bladder or storage pack.  It's meant only for filtering water as needed.

Side by Side - LifeStraw vs Sawyer

LifeStraw

Visually, the Sawyer and Lifestraw filters are pretty similar.  They both have long, hollow tube filters with an inlet and an outlet.  The main advantage of the Sawyer filter is that it can easily connect to a water bottle or storage bag so you can filter larger quantities of water and store them for the later.

The Lifestraw is very limited because it can only filter on demand and is not meant for storing water for later.

Sawyer

Spec Comparison

In addition to the usability advantages of the Sawyer, it's also a better filter from a technical standpoint.  Here's a comparison of the Sawyer and Lifestraw filters, clearly showing why the Sawyer is the better water filter.

Sawyer Squeeze vs LifeStraw

Sawyer Squeeze

LifeStraw

Filter Material

Hollow Fiber

Hollow Fiber

Weight

3 ounces

2 ounces

Flow Rate

2.0 Liters/minute

0.2 Liters/minute

Cost

$

$

Filtration Lifespan

100,000 gallons

264 gallons

User Ratings

Check Lowest Prices

Two of the most important things about your water filter are the flow rate and the life span.  How fast can it filter water and how long will it last?  

In these 2 categories, the Sawyer destroys the Lifestraw.  Not only is the flow rate 10x higher at 2.0 liters per minute vs just 0.2 liters per minute on the Lifestraw; but the lifespan of the Sawyer is 100,000 gallons vs just 264 gallons on the Lifestraw.

If you go hiking a couple of times per year and assume about 3 gallon per day of filtration needs, the Lifestraw will probably last you about 5 years.  But for the same price and size, you can get a filter that will last 40x as long which is basically a lifetime guarantee.  You just won't get that with the Lifestraw.  

There's no reason to choose the Lifestraw over the Sawyer Squeeze.  The Sawyer can do everything the Lifestraw does and more.  This comparison is an easy one.  The Sawyer is the hands down winner in every category and is our top recommendation.

Sawyer Squeeze Summary

Pros

  • Flow rate of 2.0 L/min is very fast.
  • Lifespan of 100,000 gallons.
  • Cheap, easy to operate.

Cons

  • Can get clogged easily and require backflushing.
  • Squeezing to filter can get tiring.

The Sawyer Squeeze is a no brainer when compared to the LifeStraw.  It's easier to use, lasts longer, and has a much higher flow rate.  The Sawyer filter is superior to the LifeStraw in every way possible.

By | 2018-02-01T02:43:06+00:00 January 31st, 2018|Categories: Other Gear|Tags: |Comments Off on Sawyer vs Lifestraw – Which Water Filter is Better?

About the Author: